<
Water and Security Issues in the Middle East
By: Batir Mohammad Ali Wardam
December 26, 1999
IUCN national office Jordan
The water and security
issue in Jordan and the Middle East is of great vitality since this
region has virtually ran out of water. So many potential sources of
conflicts are being incarnated at an alarming rate, this conflict is
both interstate and intrastate. The term "security" itself
is now taking a new shape in international relations.
The current trends of
globalization and third wave " communication revolution"
have resulted in the emergence of the " universal citizen"
sense in the international community. Accordingly, several
geopolitical and environmental concepts have been linked together,
forcing clear modifications in their definitions. One of those
modified concepts is that of "Security".
Security has been traditionally dealt with as a
strictly militaristic concept associated with security of borders and
national institutions from outside. Now researchers and scholars are
moving away from that narrow definition to a more wide and holistic
approach encompassing environmental security in terms of equitable
resource management and combating environmental degradation of
life support systems.
Such a concept is vital for the Middle East in
particular. Water is the predominant environmental threat to the
security of the region, whether the security is interstate or
intrastate. HM King Abdullah II was among several leaders in the
region to call for joint and collaborative efforts to combat water
scarcity and distribution problems in the region. Other wise, this
issue might ignite violent conflicts in the future.
Water Security could be defined within several
criteria including stability of societies, inequitable distribution of
water resources, scarcity and low affordability of water as well as
degradation of water quality. All these elements, unfortunately, are
reflected in the water dilemma in Jordan.
On the other hand, another integral concept of
water Security is Equity. This is manifested in the equitable
sharing of affordable resources, which relates to regional,
sectoral and intergenerational equity.
Equity has emerged as an important key element of
water security due to the fact that globalization trends have
increased the proportion of " marginalised" people around
the world; those who are being " discriminated against" on
the basis of access to economic power and capital. Equitable sharing
of environmental (natural ) resources is proving to be both ethically
and an environmentally sustainable policy. The UN General Assembly in
1997 has adopted the concept of " Equitable Sharing"
officially to be a basic concept in Environmental Law pertaining to
water issues in particular.
Natural resources are becoming either a source of
conflict or a point of cooperation. This will depend on the existence
of conflict resolving tradition and mechanisms between states and
between several stakeholders in the community. Unfortunately, the
Middle East region is lacking this tradition, thus one of the main
objectives of any plan to tackle water security issues will be to
facilitate the establishment of such a mechanism and tradition.
The water agenda in the Middle East is rich with
bad indicators, the facts and figures which point to existing and
potential problems.
Shortages in water resources have reached crises
levels. The per capita consumption of countries like Jordan has
reached an alarming scarcity. Compared to what is internationally
conceived as adequate water consumption at 1000 cubic meters/ year and
water scarcity level at 500 cubic meters, Jordanians have a share of
350 cubic meters per capita. There is no common vision between states
in the region on how to manage water crises especially in
transboundary dimensions.
Added to that, most of freshwater resources of any
single country originate from a neighboring country. This will lead
into conflicts of rights between riparian countries. The desire of one
country to control the water resources originating from its
territories or managing it individually may lead to negative reactions
from neighboring countries which get negatively affected (i.e. Turkey
vs. Syria and Iraq).
Several international agreements on water sharing
have not been implemented or abided with. Even detailed peace treaties
in some cases leave a room for different interpretations of a single
reference text (Jordanian Israeli peace treaty). There is a
general lack of adherence to International Law principles in
arbitrating water issues.
Some important projects are taking place in the
region aiming at ensuring water security. One of these initiatives has
been launched by the IUCN West Asia and North Africa regional
Committee. It will tackle water and security issues from a purely
ecological perspective. Hopefully, this project will be building up
momentum in the coming months to present a unified regional view on
this sensitive issue in the Amman 2000 World Conservation Congress to
reach a consensus on how to manage scarce resources equitably and
peacefully.
|